I am from out of town and this restaurant was recommended to me by a local friend. They didn't steer me wrong.
The service and food were excellent.
If you're not sure what to get, go with the Managers Special so you can try 2 types of sauce on your pasta. It's definitely worth a visit.
Jennifer McDowell
-
August 05, 2024
The atmosphere is really great here. Old school wood with a train car by the entrance. The lasagna was fresh and loved the various sauces. The salad and house bread were nothing special, but I loved the cotton candy drink, and the complementary spumoni was nice at the end.
R. W.
-
August 19, 2024
We were greeted when we walked in. There wasn't a wait. It's a darker vibe in the restaurant. I've been wanting to try this spot out for a few years and was super excited just to be DISAPPOINTED. We had the garlic/cheese bread. It was too soft like it could've cooked for another 2 minutes or so. The spinach and artichoke dip lacked seasoning. I wished they would've buttered the bread. I tried adding crushed red pepper, salt, and pepper. It was still a no for me. He ordered shrimp alfrdedo. The shrimp had a very loud smell , and he couldn't finish his food. I ordered fettuccine, and it also lacked seasoning. We both ordered strawberry lemonade. I asked for mine to be spiked and had NO IDEA that was going to cost me $21.50 for a drink. Never again. I was not happy at all. The bill was $80 for a bunch of nasty food. I planned on taking the food home to doctor it up because that was expensive and ended up giving it to a homeless man outside. I hope he enjoyed it more than I did. Unfortunately, we had to go somewhere else to eat and spend more money.
Miranda Luppino
-
December 08, 2024
We had a wonderful time here! Most of us enjoyed the Mizithra with Browned butter. It was delicious! Our server Tony was top notch as well! He provided exceptional service! Thank you Tony!!
Matt Calhoun
-
August 13, 2024
Love the Old Spaghetti Factory! 🍝 I've gone there for decades. My only quibble is the price is too high for what it is. The point of this restaurant was get good food for a good price. 👍 That is no longer the case. But, the salads are bigger and everything tastes as good or better than the past. The Spumoni is delicious! Secret: Order a Barques Rootbeer and ask for your free spumoni before dinner. Make a delicious spumoni float. I used to make those when I worked there.
Our Address
210 S Meridian St, Indianapolis, IN 46225, USA
Claim Listing: The Old Spaghetti Factory
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
I am from out of town and this restaurant was recommended to me by a local friend. They didn't steer me wrong. The service and food were excellent. If you're not sure what to get, go with the Managers Special so you can try 2 types of sauce on your pasta. It's definitely worth a visit.
The atmosphere is really great here. Old school wood with a train car by the entrance. The lasagna was fresh and loved the various sauces. The salad and house bread were nothing special, but I loved the cotton candy drink, and the complementary spumoni was nice at the end.
We were greeted when we walked in. There wasn't a wait. It's a darker vibe in the restaurant. I've been wanting to try this spot out for a few years and was super excited just to be DISAPPOINTED. We had the garlic/cheese bread. It was too soft like it could've cooked for another 2 minutes or so. The spinach and artichoke dip lacked seasoning. I wished they would've buttered the bread. I tried adding crushed red pepper, salt, and pepper. It was still a no for me. He ordered shrimp alfrdedo. The shrimp had a very loud smell , and he couldn't finish his food. I ordered fettuccine, and it also lacked seasoning. We both ordered strawberry lemonade. I asked for mine to be spiked and had NO IDEA that was going to cost me $21.50 for a drink. Never again. I was not happy at all. The bill was $80 for a bunch of nasty food. I planned on taking the food home to doctor it up because that was expensive and ended up giving it to a homeless man outside. I hope he enjoyed it more than I did. Unfortunately, we had to go somewhere else to eat and spend more money.
We had a wonderful time here! Most of us enjoyed the Mizithra with Browned butter. It was delicious! Our server Tony was top notch as well! He provided exceptional service! Thank you Tony!!
Love the Old Spaghetti Factory! 🍝 I've gone there for decades. My only quibble is the price is too high for what it is. The point of this restaurant was get good food for a good price. 👍 That is no longer the case. But, the salads are bigger and everything tastes as good or better than the past. The Spumoni is delicious! Secret: Order a Barques Rootbeer and ask for your free spumoni before dinner. Make a delicious spumoni float. I used to make those when I worked there.